Anx was a gem of a woman who knew most things about Adobe CS & Mac. Whenever I was stumped, I knew she'd have the answer. Sadly, for me, her growing children and her job needed more time and she's no longer a 'go-to' genius for me. I hope she's flourishing in the far reaches of Scandinavia. You are missed!
Her tip was how to create 'digital' look-alike Bazzill Orange Peel Cardstock.
Make a new 12x12 layer with the color of your choice.
Create a new adjustment layer.
Choose Pattern, Artist Surface, then stone
Adjust to about 500%
Choose the Multiply blend mode (or one that works better with your color_
Adjust opacity of about 20% (again depending on your color)
Thank you again Anx.